Thomas Tuchel left Cole Palmer out of his 25-man England squad for the November Nations League games against Croatia and Spain. On current form alone, the data says he should be in it, and near the front of the queue. His Scout52 Score of 8.6 is the highest of any English attacker in Europe's top five leagues, and among the attacking players Tuchel picked only Jude Bellingham scores higher. His chance creation and passing are both in the top 10% of Tier 1 attackers his age. The one part of his game that is below par this season is goals.
- It leaves out fitness, availability and Palmer's withdrawal from the September camp, which Tuchel has linked to the decision.
- League matches only, 2026/27, data as of 13/11/2026. Every player is scored against players in the same position across the top five European leagues (Tier 1).
- Palmer is rated as an Attacking Playmaker, a profile we added in November 2026 for attackers whose game is built on creating and passing. How the archetypes are built.
- Eight to twelve league games is an early sample. Eberechi Eze (231 minutes) and Rio Ngumoha (203 minutes) have played too little for a fair score, so they are shown but not judged.
- We have compared Palmer with the attacking players in the squad. Defenders, goalkeepers and the deeper midfielders are left out.
The squad, and who played against Croatia
Tuchel named his squad on 6 November. Palmer, Phil Foden and Kobbie Mainoo were left out, and Jobe Bellingham and Josh King were called up for the first time. Tuchel said the decision on Palmer was "not personal" and that the door is still open.
England beat Croatia 2-1 at Wembley on 12 November. Morgan Rogers opened the scoring after 24 minutes, Petar Sučić equalised, and Harry Kane scored the winning penalty on the night he became England's most-capped player.
- Starting XI (4-2-3-1): Pickford; Alexander-Arnold, Quansah, Burn, Hall; Rice, Anderson; Rogers, J. Bellingham, Gordon; Kane.
- Substitutes used: Ngumoha for Gordon (77), Garner for Rice (77), White for Alexander-Arnold (78).
- Unused attacking options: Gibbs-White, Eze, King, Calvert-Lewin, Jobe Bellingham.
Five of the squad's attacking players did not get on the pitch, and Ngumoha came on with 13 minutes left.
Palmer against the attacking players Tuchel picked
| Player | Mins | G | A | Scout52 Score | v Croatia |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jude BellinghamElite Box-to-Box · Real Madrid | 957 | 4 | 3 | 9.08 | Started |
| Cole PalmerAttacking Playmaker · Chelsea | 888 | 3 | 3 | 8.57 | Not selected |
| Harry KaneCreative Forward · Bayern Munich | 715 | 4 | 8 | 8.31 | Started, scored |
| Morgan RogersInside Forward · Chelsea | 883 | 5 | 1 | 8.19 | Started, scored |
| Morgan Gibbs-WhiteAttacking Playmaker · Nottingham Forest | 810 | 1 | 3 | 8.09 | Unused |
| Anthony GordonElite Attacking Playmaker · Barcelona | 683 | 2 | 4 | 7.99 | Started, off 77 |
| Josh KingAttacking Midfielder · Fulham | 813 | 2 | 1 | 7.07 | Unused |
| Dominic Calvert-LewinTarget Forward · Leeds | 866 | 3 | 1 | 5.90 | Unused |
| Jobe BellinghamAdvanced Playmaker · Borussia Dortmund | 644 | 0 | 2 | 5.76 | Unused |
| Rio NgumohaToo few minutes · Liverpool | 203 | 0 | 0 | – | On 77 |
| Eberechi EzeToo few minutes · Arsenal | 231 | 0 | 0 | – | Unused |
League matches only, 2026/27, as of 13/11/2026. Green = highest Scout52 Score, red = lowest of the players with a fair sample. Palmer would be second in this group, behind only Jude Bellingham.
Among the 15 English attackers with 450 or more league minutes in the top five leagues, Palmer has the highest Scout52 Score. Across all 186 Tier 1 attackers with that many minutes he ranks 18th, inside the top 10%, and he is third of the 30 Premier League attackers.
Where Palmer is Elite: making chances
The case for Palmer is the creative side of his game. His Chance Creation score is 9.3, Elite, from 2.2 key passes per 90, 21st of the 186 Tier 1 attackers. Passing is 9.0, also Elite. Both are in the top 10% of attackers aged 24 to 29, and those two scores are exactly what an Attacking Playmaker is judged on. His average match rating of 7.25 is better than 95% of Tier 1 attackers.
He is also putting in a shift without the ball. His Defensive score is 7.6, Good, with 1.8 tackles and interceptions per 90. That is in the top 25% for his age group, and higher than Rogers, Gordon or Gibbs-White.
Where he falls short: goals
The weak spot is clear. Goal Threat is 4.0, Average. Palmer has three league goals, one of them a penalty, so 0.20 non-penalty goals per 90. That ranks 113th of 186 Tier 1 attackers. Only 45% of his shots have been on target. His Duels score is 4.2, Average: he is winning 47% of his duels and 47% of his take-ons.
For a player whose reputation was built on goals, this is the gap in the profile. The creating is there. The finishing so far this season is not.
Palmer v Rogers: same club, same minutes
The fairest comparison is the one inside Chelsea's own squad. Palmer and Morgan Rogers have played almost the same minutes in the same team and have identical goal involvements per 90. They get there in very different ways.
| Measure | Palmer | Rogers |
|---|---|---|
| Scout52 Score | 8.57 | 8.19 |
| Archetype | Attacking Playmaker | Inside Forward |
| Minutes | 888 | 883 |
| Goals + assists per 90 | 0.61 | 0.61 |
| Non-penalty goals per 90 | 0.20 | 0.51 |
| Key passes per 90 | 2.23 | 1.73 |
| Chance Creation | 9.3 | 7.1 |
| Passing | 9.0 | 7.6 |
| Defensive | 7.6 | 5.6 |
| Goal Threat | 4.0 | 8.2 |
| Ball Carry | 6.8 | 7.9 |
| Duels | 4.2 | 6.8 |
Green = the better of the two, red = a weakness. Palmer wins on creating, passing and defending, and on the Score. Rogers wins on goals, carrying and duels.
Palmer is the better playmaker; Rogers is the bigger goal threat, and he showed it against Croatia. That is the real selection question. In a front line around Kane, with Jude Bellingham already creating from the No. 10 role, England may want a wide player who scores more than one who creates. On the overall numbers, though, Palmer is ahead.
Ahead of the players on the bench
The data clearly backs Palmer against the players who did not get on against Croatia, and against Gordon, who started.
- Anthony Gordon (7.99) is rated an Elite Attacking Playmaker, the same profile as Palmer. "Elite" only measures how strongly a player fits his profile: for an Attacking Playmaker that is 60% Chance Creation and 40% Passing, and it has to be in the top 10% of Tier 1 attackers. Gordon's Chance Creation (9.5) and Passing (9.1) are both a fraction higher than Palmer's, helped by more assists (0.53 per 90 against 0.30) and better pass accuracy (89% against 83%), so he clears that line and Palmer misses it by a whisker. The Scout52 Score looks at the whole player, and there Palmer is clearly ahead: his match ratings are better than 95% of Tier 1 attackers (Gordon 83%), and he is far stronger on Defensive (7.6 against 4.2) and Duels (4.2 against 1.2).
- Morgan Gibbs-White (8.09) is also an Attacking Playmaker, with even higher Chance Creation (9.6). But his only league goal is a penalty, and his Goal Threat is 0.3, Poor. If England want that type of player, Palmer is the stronger version.
- Josh King (7.07), aged 19, is the opposite profile: Goal Threat 9.1, with less creation (6.3). He is a call-up for the future as much as for now.
- Dominic Calvert-Lewin (5.90) is a Target Forward in the squad as cover for Kane. He is not a like-for-like alternative to Palmer, so the gap in Score tells you less here.
- Jobe Bellingham (5.76) is an Advanced Playmaker at Dortmund with no league goals yet. His Defensive score (8.6) is the strength of his profile, not his attacking output.
Two more names the data would put forward
If the squad were picked on Scout52 numbers alone, two more English players would be in the conversation ahead of some of those named.
Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall
Cameron Archer
Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall is, after Palmer, the highest-scoring English midfielder or attacker not in the squad. He ranks 25th of 391 Tier 1 midfielders, scores and creates (Goal Threat 9.2, Chance Creation 8.6), and his match rating of 7.47 is better than 97% of them. On these numbers he is ahead of Kane, Rogers and every other attacking player Tuchel picked except Jude Bellingham.
Cameron Archer is a pure finisher. Six league goals for Auxerre, none of them penalties, 0.76 per 90 and a Goal Threat of 9.5. He also presses: his Defensive score is 8.5. But his Chance Creation is 0.8, so he is a No. 9 option, not a creator. His Score (7.97) is level with Gordon's.
The best English attacker on the numbers, with one gap
On form alone, Palmer belongs in the 25. His Scout52 Score is the highest of any English attacker in the top five leagues, higher than Kane, Rogers and Gordon, who started against Croatia, and well clear of the attacking players who stayed on the bench. His creating and passing are Elite against the best attackers in Europe.
The flag is goals. At 0.20 non-penalty goals per 90 he is scoring less than half as often as Rogers, and England's front line already has its main creators in Kane and Jude Bellingham. Palmer's case is as the best playmaker England have outside the squad. Whether that wins him a starting place depends on whether Tuchel wants another creator or another scorer.
The Bottom Line
Leaving fitness and the September camp aside, Palmer's 2026/27 data does more than earn him a call-up. He is the highest-scoring English attacker in the top five leagues on the Scout52 Score, ahead of every attacking player Tuchel picked except Jude Bellingham, and his chance creation and passing are in the top 10% of Tier 1 attackers his age. The one gap is goals: 0.20 non-penalty goals per 90 against Rogers' 0.51. If those start going in for Chelsea, there is very little left in the numbers to argue against him.
See the Composite Data Behind Every Player
Scout52 scores every player out of 10 on six composites, ranked against players in the same position at the same level, across 100+ leagues. The player data is on Scout Pro, £19.99 a month, with a 7-day free trial and no card needed. Built by academy recruitment professionals.
Start Free Trial